SigFig vs. Wealthfront: which is right for you?

SigFig and Wealthfront both provide robo-advisor services, but they are structured differently.

Here is a breakdown of the key differences between the two companies:

SigFig vs. Wealthfront: Key services

SigFig and Wealthfront both provide software-based discretionary portfolio management. 

SigFig:

• Model portfolios: SigFig currently provides advice on model portfolios that primarily include mutual funds and ETFs, with some individual stocks and other holdings.
• Rebalancing: SigFig monitors managed accounts and rebalances portfolios when needed.
• Free portfolio tracking: Users can link external brokerage accounts to SigFig’s platform to view holdings and portfolio information.
• Tax-loss harvesting: SigFig provides tax-loss harvesting where applicable.

Wealthfront:

• Automated portfolios: Wealthfront’s Automated Investing Account provides discretionary, automated portfolio management based on risk tolerance and long-term goals.
• Portfolio customization: Clients with taxable accounts and IRAs can customize eligible Classic and SRI portfolios by adjusting allocations.
• Tax-loss harvesting: Wealthfront applies tax-loss harvesting for certain taxable accounts and offers direct indexing for taxable Automated Investing Accounts with at least $100,000.
• Advanced automated options: Wealthfront discloses related automated services, including an Automated Bond Portfolio, Automated Bond Ladder, S&P 500 Direct, and Nasdaq-100 Direct.

SigFig vs. Wealthfront: Fees

SigFig discloses a variable fee structure generally no greater than 0.50% of assets under management (AUM), while Wealthfront charges a fixed 0.25% annual wrap fee for its automated investing account.

SigFig:

• First $10,000: No management fee
• More than $10,000: Management fee is 0.25% annually
• ETF expense ratios: Average embedded ETF expense ratio of 0.07% to 0.15%, depending on brokerage
• Flat fee: Generally, no greater than 0.50% of assets under management

Wealthfront:

• Advisory fee: The Automated Investing Account charges a 0.25% annual wrap fee.
• Other costs: Clients may still pay ETF or fund expense ratios, which vary by portfolio allocation.
• Related automated portfolios: Wealthfront discloses different fees for certain other automated accounts, including 0.15% forthe  Automated Bond Ladder, 0.09% forthe  S&P 500 Direct, and 0.12% forthe  Nasdaq-100 Direct.

SigFig vs. Wealthfront: Minimum account sizes

The main difference is the starting balance. 

SigFig:

• Main advisory minimum: Generally, imposes a $2,000 minimum investment for clients.

Wealthfront:

• Automated Investing Account: The minimum to open the account is $500
• S&P 500 Direct and Nasdaq-100 Direct: The minimum to open either account is $5,000.
• US Direct Indexing: Clients need at least $100,000 in a taxable Automated Investing Account to opt in.
• Mart Beta: Clients need at least $500,000 in a taxable Automated Investing Account to opt in.

SigFig vs. Wealthfront: Pros and cons

Here is a look at the pros and cons of both SigFig and Wealthfront to help you decide which is the right fit for you.

Pros of SigFig:

• Free portfolio tracker: SigFig states that portfolio tracking is provided without charge.
• Discretionary management: Clients do not simply receive suggestions; SigFig can manage, trade, and rebalance the managed account under the advisory agreement.
• Tax-aware features: Optional tax-loss harvesting is available where activated and applicable, though clients remain responsible for tax consequences.

Cons of SigFig:

• Account minimum: SigFig generally requires a $2,000 minimum investment for managed accounts, which may be a barrier for investors starting with smaller balances.
• Limited advisory scope: SigFig’s advice is currently focused on model portfolios, primarily mutual funds and ETFs, rather than broad financial planning.
• Fee schedule not fully simple: Clients may pay a flat fee or asset-based fee, generally no greater than 0.50% of AUM, while fee arrangements may vary by agreement.

Pros of Wealthfront:

• Lower starting minimum: The $500 minimum makes the main automated account easier to start for smaller balances.
• Automated tax features: Tax-loss harvesting is available for taxable accounts, with direct indexing at higher balances.
• Higher-balance features: Direct Indexing and Smart Beta are available at disclosed balance thresholds

Cons of Wealthfront:

• Higher thresholds for advanced features: Direct indexing and Smart Beta require much larger taxable account balances.
• Software-based relationship: Wealthfront’s program brochure states that the service is likely not appropriate for investors seeking frequent advisor feedback.
• Tax features have limits: Tax-loss harvesting is not tax advice and depends on the client’s wider tax situation.

SigFig vs. Wealthfront: Technology and security

SigFig’s digital experience emphasizes linked-account portfolio tracking and analysis. 

Users can link external brokerage accounts, view holdings, track performance, review portfolio analytics, and access managed-account information through its web platform and mobile apps.

Wealthfront provides access through its own app and site. 

Wealthfront’s digital platform is more advanced on automated investing tools, including portfolio rebalancing, dividend reinvestment, tax-loss harvesting, direct indexing, and portfolio customization.

For security, SigFig states that managed accounts come with SIPC coverage, which allows qualified custodians to hold client assets. It also discloses encrypted brokerage credentials, secure transmission, restricted database access, 256-bit SSL encryption, and third-party security testing.

Wealthfront has a dedicated security page for reporting account security issues and service vulnerabilities. Wealthfront also states that investments are not protected from market movements, but eligible assets may be insured by SIPC up to $500,000, including $250,000 for cash, if Wealthfront were to fail.

Final verdict: SigFig vs. Wealthfront

SigFig and Wealthfront both provide robo-advisor portfolio management, but they address different user needs. 

SigFig combines discretionary robo-advisor portfolio management with portfolio-tracking tools that allow users and clients to sync external brokerage account data, track portfolios, manage model portfolios, rebalance, and optionally harvest tax losses. 

Wealthfront focuses on a defined automated investing account with a $500 minimum, a 0.25% annual wrap fee, eligible portfolio customization, tax-loss harvesting, and higher-balance features such as US Direct Indexing and Smart Beta.

Get expert financial advice

If you're seeking professional financial advice, Unbiased can match you with a financial advisor who will help you manage your money and maximize your investments.