SigFig vs Betterment review

SigFig vs. Betterment: Which is right for you?

SigFig and Betterment both provide robo-advisor services.

SigFig’s reviewed service is a discretionary digital investment advisory and portfolio management service. It uses web-based technology, risk profile information, existing portfolio data, model portfolios, and rebalancing logic to manage client accounts.

Betterment’s reviewed service is an internet-based automated investing service. It builds managed portfolios around client goals, risk levels, and time horizons, with an optional Premium tier that includes access to financial consultants and CFP professionals.

Here is a breakdown of the key differences between the two companies:

SigFig vs Betterment: Key services

SigFig’s service is centered on portfolio tracking, model-based recommendations, and discretionary account management. Betterment’s service is centered on goal-based automated investing, with Premium advice available at a higher balance.

SigFig:

• Model portfolios: SigFig currently provides advice for model portfolios that include mainly mutual funds and ETFs, with some individual stocks and other holdings.
• Rebalancing: SigFig monitors managed accounts and rebalances portfolios when needed.
• Free portfolio tracking: Users can link external brokerage accounts to SigFig’s platform to view holdings and portfolio information.
• Tax-loss harvesting: SigFig provides tax-loss harvesting where applicable.

Betterment:

• Automated portfolio management: Betterment continuously monitors your portfolio, rebalances when it drifts, and reinvests dividends to keep allocations aligned with your goals. 
• Tax-efficient investing: Betterment manages tax-related features such as tax-loss harvesting and tax management for eligible accounts.
• Goal-based setup and ETF portfolios: Betterment builds portfolios around client goals, time horizons, and risk levels, using diversified ETF portfolios.
• Portfolio options: Clients can choose from curated portfolio strategies, including Core, Value Tilt, and socially responsible options such as Broad Impact, Climate Impact, and Social Impact.
• Cash and advisor services: Betterment offers a Cash Reserve high-yield savings account integrated with investing, while the Premium plan adds unlimited access to financial advisors beyond the Digital plan’s automated tools.

SigFig vs. Betterment: Fees

SigFig and Betterment both charge for automated portfolio management, but their fee schedules use different breakpoints.

SigFig’s consumer-facing pricing is built around a $10,000 managed-asset threshold, while Betterment uses monthly pricing for smaller Digital accounts and percentage-based pricing once the account meets its balance or recurring-deposit conditions.

Betterment charges a percentage-based advisory fee with two service tiers, while Acorns applies flat monthly subscription fees that bundle multiple account features. Both platforms build investment portfolios primarily with ETFs, and clients also bear the standard fund-level expenses associated with those holdings.

SigFig:

• First $10,000: No management fee
• More than $10,000: Management fee is 0.25% annually
• ETF expense ratios: Average embedded ETF expense ratio of 0.07% to 0.15%, depending on brokerage
• Flat fee: Generally, no greater than 0.50% of assets under management

Betterment:

• Digital fee: Betterment Digital costs $5 per month for investing accounts below $24,000.
• Digital percentage fee: Betterment Digital moves to 0.25% annually when the client has $200 or more in monthly recurring deposits or transfers or reaches $24,000 to $1 million in Betterment investing balances.
• Premium fee: Betterment Premium charges 0.65% annually on the first $1 million.
• High-balance discounts: Eligible investing balances from $1 million to $2 million are charged 0.15% on that tier, and balances above $2 million are charged 0.10% on that tier.
• Other costs: ETF expense ratios apply in addition to Betterment’s management fee.

SigFig vs. Betterment: Minimum account sizes

One of the clearest differences between SigFig and Betterment is the minimum investment requirement. 

SigFig generally requires at least $2,000 to access its managed advisory service, while Betterment Digital has no minimum account balance. 

Betterment Premium, however, requires $100,000 in eligible investments to access human advisor support. 

SigFig:

• Standard robo-advisor minimum general is $2,000

Betterment:

• No required investment account balance
• The minimum deposit is $10
• $50 portfolio balance threshold for rebalancing eligibility
• $100,000 minimum investing balance for Premium

SigFig vs. Betterment: Pros and cons

Here is a look at the pros and cons of both SigFig and Betterment to help you decide which is the right fit for you.

Pros of SigFig:

• Free portfolio tracker: SigFig states that portfolio tracking is provided without charge.
• Discretionary management: Clients do not simply receive suggestions; SigFig can manage, trade, and rebalance the managed account under the advisory agreement.
• Tax-aware features: Optional tax-loss harvesting is available where activated and applicable, though clients remain responsible for tax consequences.

Cons of SigFig:

• Account minimum: SigFig generally requires a $2,000 minimum investment for managed accounts, which may be a barrier for investors starting with smaller balances.
• Limited advisory scope: SigFig’s advice is currently focused on model portfolios, primarily mutual funds and ETFs, rather than broad financial planning.
• Fee schedule not fully simple: Clients may pay a flat fee or asset-based fee, generally no greater than 0.50% of AUM, while fee arrangements may vary by agreement.

Pros of Betterment:

• Low entry point: Digital investing has no required account minimum and a $10 deposit minimum.
• Published pricing: Betterment clearly separates Digital and Premium pricing, which makes the cost structure easier to compare before opening an account.
• Tax-efficient investing tools: Betterment offers tax-loss harvesting and other tax-management features for eligible managed accounts, which can help taxable investors manage tax drag.
• Portfolio choice: Betterment offers curated portfolio strategies, including Core, Value Tilt, and socially responsible options.

Cons of Betterment:

• Premium requires a high balance: This limits expert access to investors with at least $100,000.
• ETF expense ratios add to overall costs: ETF expense ratios are part of the underlying funds and are charged in addition to Betterment’s advisory fees, which means overall costs can be higher than the advisory fee alone.
• Limited planning scope: Betterment’s internet-based advisory service is designed for discrete financial goals, not comprehensive planning for every part of a client’s financial life.

SigFig vs. Betterment: Technology and security

Technology and account security are central to the user experience with robo-advisors. 

SigFig:

• Client-facing tech: SigFig offers a web platform and mobile apps. Users can link external brokerage accounts, view holdings, track performance, review portfolio analytics, and access managed-account information.
• Brokerage connection: SigFig requires brokerage credentials to create a secure connection with the user’s brokerage and import financial information.
• Account control: SigFig states that only the client can direct cash movements into or out of a SigFig managed account.
• Custody and SIPC: The broker-dealers used as custodians for SigFig accounts are SIPC members.
• Usability: SigFig’s technology is built around linked-account portfolio tracking, portfolio analysis, and automated portfolio management.

Betterment:

• Client-facing tech: Betterment provides both a web platform and mobile apps .The interface supports goal tracking, account monitoring, portfolio adjustments, and access to statements, with a design built around mobile-first usability.
• Security features: Betterment employs bank-level encryption and multifactor authentication. Brokerage assets are covered by SIPC insurance up to $500,000. Betterment Cash Reserve accounts are FDIC-insured up to $2 million per individual through program banks.
• Regulatory oversight: Betterment is an SEC-registered investment advisor and Betterment Securities is a FINRA-member broker-dealer, ensuring regulatory compliance.
• Usability: With a streamlined, mobile-first design, Betterment emphasizes simplicity and automation, making it easy for investors who want a dedicated digital-only platform.

Final verdict: SigFig vs Betterment

SigFig and Betterment both provide robo-advisor portfolio management, but the user experience is organized differently. 

SigFig combines free portfolio tracking, linked external brokerage account analysis, discretionary managed portfolios, rebalancing, and optional tax-loss harvesting. 

Betterment focuses on goal-based automated investing, ETF portfolios, tax-management tools, retirement account support, and optional Premium advisor access. Betterment also offers self-directed investing, but that is separate from this robo-advisor comparison.

Get expert financial advice

If you're seeking professional financial advice, Unbiased can match you with a financial advisor who will help you manage your money and maximize your investments.