Summary
- Betterment provides robo-advisors and automated portfolio management.
- Fisher Investments offers traditional financial advisory services targeted at wealthy investors.
- Betterment's fees are tiered based on plan options and account balance.
- Fisher Investments charges fees based on Assets Under Management (AUM).
Looking for a financial advisor?
Betterment vs. Fisher Investments: what’s the difference?
Fisher Investments and Betterment serve very different investors.
Fisher, founded by Ken Fisher in 1979 and headquartered in Plano, Texas, provides discretionary portfolio management with dedicated client support, charging around 1% to 1.50% of assets.
Betterment, founded in 2008, is a digital investment advisor and robo-advisor offering automated ETF portfolios, tax management and optional human advice with a low-cost, accessible entry point.
Betterment vs. Fisher Investments: Fees and minimums
Betterment is considerably more accessible and lower cost, while Fisher Investments is designed primarily for high-net-worth investors seeking advisor-led portfolio management.
Fisher Investments | Betterment | |
|---|---|---|
Minimum investment | $1M typical | $0 |
AUM fee | 1.00%–1.25% | 0.25%–0.40% |
Flat-fee option | None | $4/month |
Trading commissions | None | None |
Human advice | Included | Available with Premium |
Best for | HNW investors | Lower-cost automated investing |
Fisher Investments uses a tiered AUM fee, starting at 1.25% on the first $1 million and falling to 1.00% above $5 million. Relationships below $1 million may be accepted at a higher 1.50% rate.
Betterment, as a robo-advisor, offers a much lower entry point, with no investment minimum. Its standard investing service costs 0.25% annually, while smaller accounts may pay a monthly fee, and higher-tier services add access to financial professionals.
Betterment vs. Fisher Investments: Pros and cons
Recognizing that both firms have distinct strengths and weaknesses, catering to different investor preferences and financial goals is essential.
Pros of Fisher Investments
- Exceptional customer service
- Ongoing advisory support
- Bespoke portfolio design based on well-researched investment strategies
Cons of Fisher Investments
- The absence of a brokerage platform
- Steep minimum investment requirement of $500,000
- Relatively higher fees compared to industry averages
Pros of Betterment
- Automated services utilizing advanced algorithms for portfolio management
- Competitive fees
- User-friendly platform for novice investors
Cons of Betterment
- Limited customization options
- Lack of face-to-face interactions with Betterment financial advisors
- Potential overreliance on algorithms for investment decisions.
What are Fisher Investment and Betterment’s specific investment strategies?
Fisher Investments uses a research-driven, actively managed strategy to build customized portfolios focused on long-term growth and risk management. In contrast, Betterment relies on automated, goal-based investing, using algorithms to create diversified portfolios aligned with individual risk profiles.
Betterment vs. Fisher Investments: Customer service
Betterment offers support by phone, email and live chat, with access to CFP professionals available through eligible advice services.
Fisher Investments provides a more relationship-led service, with clients assigned a dedicated contact for ongoing portfolio support.
For investors, Betterment suits those comfortable with digital support, while Fisher offers a more personalized, ongoing service relationship.
Are Fisher Investments and Betterment safe?
Yes. Fisher Investments and Betterment are regulated investment advisors with safeguards for client assets. Fisher client assets are held by independent third-party custodians, while Betterment brokerage accounts have SIPC protection up to applicable limits.
For investors, both provide established regulatory and asset-protection measures, although they use different investment and service models.
Can I access my Fisher Investments or Betterment accounts through their websites and mobile apps?
Fisher Investments provides a user-friendly website and mobile app interface that allows clients to access their accounts, track portfolio performance, and communicate with their financial advisors.
Betterment's website and mobile app enable clients to set up accounts, make contributions, track progress toward financial goals, and access diversified investment options. Betterment's intuitive platform caters to investors of varying expertise levels, offering a seamless experience for managing investments on the go.
Fisher Investments or Betterment: Which should I choose?
Choose Fisher Investments if you have $1 million or more and want personalized, discretionary portfolio management with dedicated support.
Choose Betterment if you want a lower-cost robo-advisor, with automated investing starting at 0.25% annually, a low entry point and optional human advice.
For personalized advice, Unbiased can match you with an SEC-regulated financial advisor based on your needs.